Currently I moderate a community across two separate platforms, which we are in the process of migrating between.

A particular user, who is generally very valuable and helpful in our current community, is disruptive and unnecessarily critical of our new platform.

The moderation team wants to make the change as painless as possible, and so we want to avoid removing this user.

What is the best way forward?

2 Answers 2


What is your relationship with this user? Have you spoken privately with them yet?

Since you have indicated that they are otherwise a valuable and helpful member of the community, your best course of action may be private, one-on-one communication.

  • Addressing this users concerns will help to get them to settle down. Even if you can't take any action to resolve the concerns, you will have at least personally addressed and given attention to the user's complaints. If you've found something that you can action... great! You've gotten valuable feedback that improved your site.
  • Attempt to create a dialog by sharing your opinions, and empathizing with the user's concerns where possible. If you disagree with the user, do so in a way that is persuasive and respectful.
  • Acknowledgement of concerns will go much further in helping them integrate to the new site than disciplining the user for very understandably being reluctant to go along with a major change from the status quo.

I would like to reiterate that you don't want to discipline the user in this case, unless they are being exceptionally hostile. In my experience, these users have some emotional investment in the 'status quo' and acting in a way that would be perceived as hostile will likewise make them more hostile -- not only to you, but to the situation and the community. It is much better to reach out to them and to continue to make them feel welcome in your community.


Handle the situation carefully. People don't like change and it is common for your most active users to like change the least. At the end of the day, if they were really active, it is because they liked the way things were. They are most likely afraid that the change to the new system will negatively impact their ability to enjoy the community they were previously happy with.

The best thing you can do is be reassuring. Listen to them, hear what their concerns are, try to comfort and reassure them when possible. Try to explain why changes are necessary and good when you can't. Leverage the fact that they like the community to help you out. If you can suggest ways that they can help the transition go smoother and possibly help them be involved in fixing problems they see, that may also help.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.